by John Herr
Note from ThatDamnAdmin: John Herr, a valued member and contributor, offers his opinion on a controversial satire video by DC comedian Tommy Taylor and the subsequent reaction from viewers. The video also features some active members of the Washington DC Comedy Writers Group. We want to publish pieces that focus on comedy in the District–even the controversial stuff. Some people find the video funny, others-not funny at all, others find it tasteless but funny, still others think it is “what’s wrong with the country/internet/insert your beef here.” The Washington DC Comedy Writers Group is a loose association of people who think about and write comedy–all kinds of comedy–from everywhere on the political and cultural spectrum. Please keep in mind that the group itself does not have opinions, political, cultural, pro-anything, or anti-anything. The individual members have plenty of opinions. As long as we keep focused on comedy in DC, we allow our members to voice opinions here. We welcome all of those opinions, and yours. That is why blogs have comment sections.
In his own contribution to March Madness, D.C.’s Tommy Taylor has released a hilarious new video that’s gone viral. Well, maybe not Joseph Kony-level viral, but at 101,000 YouTube hits and counting, viral for the D.C. comedy scene.
The filmmaker’s latest, “Abused Black Men (White Women’s Society for the Prevention of Cruelty Against Black Men),” is a parody of those tearjerking Sarah McLachlan animal adoption ads that pimp one-eyed kittens and limping Labradors to make you feel like a rat if you don’t pony up $18 a day to save their furry little asses.
Taylor’s video suggests that black men are being abused by their women, and that “good white women” are needed to “rescue” them and nurse them back to health.
Uh oh. Here comes the backlash!
“It’s making fun of a very real issue – Intimate partner violence – which disproportionally affects black couples,” wrote Britni Danielle of ClutchMagOnline.
“There’s nothing funny about it,” wrote Fahima Haque of “The Root DC” in a piece published by the Washington Post online. Haque added, “I’m neither a black man or a black woman, so maybe my taking offense is misplaced.”
Yeah, maybe.
What’s misplaced is the idea that the video maligns an entire race or gender. On the contrary, it takes aim at a target-rich environment of tropes ripe for satire:
1. The idea that white people are needed to rescue “defenseless” African-Americans from harm.
2. Those who claim the moral high ground while taking advantage of others (“Reggie, you missed a spot.”)
3. The use of famous people to manipulate viewers (“Hello, I’m a random white woman.”)
4. White people who cluelessly appropriate black language and culture (“I have all the Tyler Perry movies at home!”)
5. Guys who rationalize their cheating ways by blaming their wives and girfriends.
Several years ago, Al Franken, a former writer for Saturday Night Live, got into a running feud with Bill O’Reilly of Fox News, who was angered at Franken’s jibes. “Bill, if you’re listening right now, and I know you are, please listen closely,” Franken said. “In the United States of America, satire is protected speech, even if the object of the satire doesn’t get it.”
Fortunately, most YouTube viewers “get” Taylor’s video. They’ve given it 575 “likes” and only 72 “dislikes.” They took seriously his disclaimer (“It’s just comedy…don’t take it too serious!”).
Some of their comments:
“I found this video quite Hilarious! It is quite brilliantly executed also.”
“Reminds me of Patrice O’Neal…R.I.P.”
“All of my friends who watched this video are black/white, male/female, who have masters and Ph.Ds, and found this to be on the caliber of the Chappelle [Show] and very HILARIOUS.”
(I gotta admit, though, my favorite comment is from “redvelvetjacket”: “Can someone explain this video to me? I’m not sure I understand the point it’s trying to make.”)
Still, satire is a double-edged sword, and it can cut both ways. Check out some of the video titles YouTube suggests downloading after watching Taylor’s:
“Blame it on the Black Woman.”
“You have been lied to Black man and woman.”
“Melyssa Ford Discusses Being Violently Abused.”
“Beware of the Verbally Abusive Man…Hiding in Plain Sight.”
Yikes. To borrow from Haque, “There’s nothing funny about that.”
Not everyone thinks in comedic terms. In this polarized city, political positioning is paramount. The recent controversy over comments by Rush Limbaugh and Bill Maher underscores this fact. Words spoken in a sketch or on stage can lose their context and meaning on the printed page. Ask former Vice President George H.W. Bush (the Elder), whose sarcastic aside to a reporter — “I follow the President blindly” — was used as a weapon by his political opponents.
It’s different in the clubs. As a white comic who has played dozens of urban rooms in the DMV, I have found that comedy is colorblind. Audiences just want to laugh. And few subjects are off-limits, as long as you show respect and know what the hell you’re talking about.
Which is why we in D.C. are blessed to have skilled artists like Taylor and his merry band of brothers and sisters. Watch the video again for the great little moments — Haywood’s head shudder; Joncea’s ponytail pull. Priceless.
Now won’t you please give generously today to keep the humorless wankers ** at bay so we may enjoy many more of Tommy Taylor’s videos without worrying that they’ll set off an international incident?
Thank you.
** Never call a humorless wanker a humorless wanker to their face. Remember, they’re humorless. And wankers.
John K. Herr is a speechwriter and standup comedian who goes by the stage name “Herricane.”